× Scuba Gear
Terms of use Privacy Policy

Open Circuit and Closed Circuit Rebreathers: Which one is better?



diving board for pool

There are several types of rebreathers: closed circuit, open circuit, and "mixture" rebreathers. Each one has its pros and cons. This article will discuss the most popular rebreather types and what you should look out for when selecting a rebreather. The final section will tell you which rebreathers won't harm marine life. Whichever rebreather you choose, be sure it is compatible for the environment that you'll find yourself in.

Semi-closed circuit Rebreathers

If you're comparing semi and closed circuit rebreathers, it might be tempting to go with a closed circuit model. They are both similar in principle. However, there are some differences in the way that gas is delivered. It depends on your needs and goals as to which model you prefer, whether it is a semi-closed or closed circuit rebreather.


mini scuba tank

Continuous-flow "mixture rebreathers"

Continuous-flow rebreathers tend to be used for extended dives. The newest models allow you to inhale with the same level of oxygen as your surrounding air. This allows users to breathe easier while being protected against bacterial contamination. The rebreathers are also more durable and reliable than ever before. You won't have any problems breathing in water as long as you use them correctly.

Purging oxygen rebreathers

To ensure constant gas flow, a diver who rebreather uses oxygen. The diver's rebreather has a cylinder to store the source of gas. Pure oxygen, also known as liquid oxygen, makes breathing easier. Rebreather divers should inhale mixtures of both gases. There are two types. Active addition and passive rebreathers. Both types are identical. The difference between the rebreathers lies in their volume of gas. A diver should be aware of both methods, as this is the most effective method of preventing hypoxia.


Rebreathers don't disturb marine life

Rebreathers have one major advantage: they don't interfere with marine life. Rebreathers offer underwater diving a quieter experience than open-circuit divers, which are noisy with gushy and clogged gas. Rebreathers are also much more comfortable than other diving equipment, so the only concern you should have is how comfortable you'll be breathing.

Rebreathers costs

Rebreathers are an indispensable medical device for people in high-risk situations such as the military and law enforcement. The industry has grown due to increasing awareness of the safety and cost-savings of rebreathers. The high costs of the devices could discourage some people from using them. Listed below are a few tips to reduce the cost of rebreathers. Continue reading to learn more.


padi certificate

Safety concerns for divers who use rebreathers

While safety issues surrounding rebreathers are relatively rare, they do exist. Rebreather diving is up to 10 times more risky than open-circuit scuba, according to some studies. Rebreather diving actually causes fewer deaths than base jumping or skydiving. Rebreathers must be diligent and determined in applying safety protocols to minimize risks.



 



Open Circuit and Closed Circuit Rebreathers: Which one is better?